You want to sell your car in Dallas and walk away with the most cash possible. But with so many options — CarMax, Carvana, dealerships, private sales, Facebook Marketplace — how do you know which one is actually the best place to sell your car?
We've been buying cars in the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex for years. Here's the truth about every option, who each one is best for, and how to get the maximum payout for your vehicle.
Quick Comparison: Your Options in Dallas
| Option | Typical Payout | Time to Cash | Hassle Level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Private Sale (Craigslist, FB) | Highest (if lucky) | Weeks to months | High |
| Local Dealer/Cash Buyer | High | Same day | Low |
| CarMax | Medium | Same day | Low |
| Carvana | Medium (varies) | 1-3 days | Low |
| Dealership Trade-In | Lowest | Same day | Low |
Option 1: Private Sale (Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist)
Best for: Patient sellers with desirable cars who don't mind dealing with strangers
In theory, selling privately gets you the most money because there's no middleman. In practice? It's a nightmare for most people.
The reality of private sales in Dallas:
- Endless lowball offers and no-shows
- Scam attempts (fake cashier's checks, "I'll send my shipper")
- Strangers coming to your home for test drives
- Liability until the title is properly transferred
- Weeks or months of your time
Private sales make sense if you have a rare or collectible car where buyer demand is high. For a typical Honda, Toyota, or Ford? The extra few hundred dollars usually isn't worth the headache.
Option 2: CarMax Dallas Locations
Best for: People who value certainty and don't want to negotiate
CarMax has multiple locations in DFW — Irving, Plano, Fort Worth, and more. Their process is simple: drive in, wait for an appraisal, get a written offer good for 7 days.
Pros:
- Straightforward, no-haggle process
- Professional experience
- They'll buy any car in any condition
- Offer is valid for 7 days
Cons:
- Offers typically 5-15% below what you could get elsewhere
- Long wait times (1-2 hours on weekends)
- National pricing algorithm doesn't reflect Dallas market demand
CarMax is a solid baseline offer. Get one, but don't stop there.
Option 3: Carvana
Best for: Convenience-first sellers who want an instant online quote
Carvana's pitch is appealing: get an offer online in minutes, they pick up your car, done. And sometimes their algorithm spits out surprisingly good offers.
The catch? Carvana offers are notoriously inconsistent. We've seen them offer $3,000 above market on one car and $4,000 below on another nearly identical vehicle. It's algorithm roulette.
Also common: offer changes after their inspection. That quote you got online? It can drop by thousands once they see the car in person.
Worth getting a quote? Absolutely — it takes 2 minutes. Just don't assume it's your best option.
Option 4: Local Car Buying Services
Best for: Sellers who want maximum payout with minimal hassle
Here's where most Dallas sellers leave money on the table. Local car buyers like Crescent Motors can often beat the national chains because:
- We know the Dallas market. A Toyota Tundra is worth more here than in Miami. National algorithms miss this.
- Lower overhead. No Super Bowl ads or Manhattan headquarters to pay for.
- Direct sales. We often sell directly to end buyers, avoiding auction fees.
- Faster decisions. No corporate approval chains. We can make a decision on the spot.
The best local buyers offer same-day payment, free pickup, and handle all the paperwork. No different from CarMax or Carvana in terms of convenience — but often $1,000-3,000 more in your pocket.
Option 5: Dealership Trade-In
Best for: Almost no one (seriously)
If you're buying another car, trading in seems convenient. But here's what dealers don't tell you: trade-in values are almost always the lowest offers you'll get.
Dealers make it seem like they're giving you a great trade-in value by adjusting the numbers on the new car. It's a shell game. You're better off selling your car separately and negotiating the new purchase independently.
Read more: Trade-In vs. Selling Your Car: Which Is Better?
The Smart Strategy: Get Multiple Offers
The sellers who get the most money follow a simple process:
- Get a Carvana quote online (2 minutes)
- Get a CarMax quote at a nearby location (or use their online estimate)
- Get 2-3 local dealer quotes — including Crescent Motors
- Compare all offers and take the highest one
This takes about an hour total and can put thousands of extra dollars in your pocket. The difference between the lowest and highest offer is often $2,000-5,000.
Where to Sell Based on Your Situation
You have a 2018+ car in good condition:
Get multiple quotes from local dealers. You have the leverage — your car is desirable. Don't settle for the first offer.
You have an older car (10+ years) or high mileage:
CarMax or local dealers are your best bet. Carvana's algorithm tends to lowball older vehicles.
You need cash TODAY:
Local cash buyers or CarMax. Both can pay same-day. Carvana usually takes a few days to schedule pickup.
You have a loan on the car:
Any legitimate buyer — CarMax, Carvana, or local dealers — can handle payoffs. Read our guide: How to Sell a Car With a Loan
Your car doesn't run:
Skip Carvana (they want running vehicles). CarMax will buy it but offer less. Local buyers who specialize in all conditions may offer more. Check out: Junk Car Buyers in Dallas
Dallas-Specific Tips
- Trucks and SUVs sell for more here. Texas loves trucks. If you have a Tundra, F-150, Silverado, or any full-size SUV, you'll get better offers locally than from national algorithms.
- Tax season (Feb-April) = higher offers. More buyers with cash means dealers need more inventory. Learn more about timing your sale.
- Hail damage is common. If your car has hail damage, disclose it upfront. Local buyers are used to it and won't lowball you as hard as national chains.
The Bottom Line
The best place to sell your car in Dallas depends on what you value most:
- Maximum cash? Get multiple quotes, prioritize local dealers.
- Maximum convenience? Carvana or CarMax — but expect to leave some money on the table.
- Best balance? Local cash buyers who offer same-day payment, free pickup, AND competitive prices.
Whatever you do, don't just accept the first offer. Spend an hour getting quotes, and you'll likely end up thousands of dollars richer.
Ready to Sell Your Car in Dallas?
Get a free, no-obligation cash offer from Crescent Motors. Same-day payment, free pickup throughout DFW, and we'll beat most CarMax and Carvana offers.
Get Your Cash Offer →